28 brokers serving Indianapolis

Local Medicare Help in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Local, licensed agents who know Indianapolis, plus licensed out-of-state brokers who serve the area. Talking to one costs you nothing.

Why call a local broker instead of a 1-800 number?

They represent several carriers

An independent broker can compare plans from multiple insurance companies side by side, rather than selling one company's product.

They know your doctors

A broker in your county knows which hospitals and physicians take which plans, and can check your prescriptions against the formulary before you enroll.

Same person next year

You get one name and one direct number: the same person who can sit down with you each fall when plans change.

17 brokers

Brokers in Indianapolis

Based in Indianapolis. These are the people who can meet you in person.

Elsewhere in Indiana

Indiana-based brokers who also serve Indianapolis.

Patricia Griffey
Page 1 AgencyElkhart, IndianaUpdated 2027

Experienced Risk Management Advisor with a demonstrated history of working in the health insurance industry.

Licensed in Indiana, based out of state

These brokers hold an active Indiana license but work from another state, so an in-person visit isn't likely.

William Gray
5.0(1 review)
The Medicare DudeDaytona Beach, FloridaLicensed in INUpdated 2027

William Gray – Top Medicare Agent in Florida | The Medicare Dude William Gray, widely known as The Medicare Dude, is a leading Medicare insurance agent in Florida…

Timothy Baggett
Amerus Insurance GroupLakeland, FloridaLicensed in INUpdated 2027

Amerus Insurance Group’s approach to serving Medicare clients is built on education, personalization, and lifelong support.

Ryan George
Part ABCPittsburgh, PennsylvaniaLicensed in INUpdated 2027

Part ABC is a licensed, independent insurance brokerage agency based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. We specialize in all things health insurance, but mainly Medicare.

Julie Kovacevich
Forthright Retirement SolutionsLas Vegas, NevadaLicensed in INUpdated 2027

Hi, my name is Julie, I am your local Medicare advisor and broker. With over 15 years of experience in the insurance industry, I am passionate about helping individuals…

Jennifer Sigman
Sigman Family AgencyCHILLICOTHE, OhioLicensed in INUpdated 2027

Sigman Family Agency is an independent insurance agency based in Chillicothe, Ohio, proudly serving clients in 18 states. Jennifer R.

David Wolfe
David Wolfe InsuranceSan Diego, CaliforniaLicensed in INUpdated 2027

Medicare Can Be Confusing. I Make It Personal and Clear. My name is David Wolfe, and I am an independent Medicare broker dedicated to helping people understand their…

Peter Joseph
Joseph Insurance Broker LLCChino, CaliforniaLicensed in INUpdated 2027

As the Owner and CEO of Joseph Insurance Broker LLC, I lead a team of over 26 agents and 1 office administrator who provide quality and customized insurance solutions to…

Jeffrey Kahler
Trent AdvisorsThe Villages, FloridaLicensed in INUpdated 2027

I’m Jeffrey Kahler, a Gen X Medicare advisor known for quiet confidence and clear guidance.

Leah Bergman
Easy Day Insurance Brea, CALicensed in INUpdated 2027

I am Leah Bergman, a Medicare insurance agent with a background in International Business and a minor in Spanish.

Mark Staffen
Core Insurance Advisors, IncFranklin, TennesseeLicensed in INUpdated 2027

With over 40 years of experience in the insurance industry, Mark Staffen brings a wealth of knowledge and proven leadership to Core Insurance Advisors.

Jamie Radder
M-Power Agency LLCAlbion, New YorkLicensed in INUpdated 2027

Jamie’s experiences span several industries including: hospitality, training, and insurance starting with Hyatt Hotels as a Corporate manager-in-training, then as a…

Jeremy Weiser
The Medicare StoreLas Vegas, NevadaLicensed in INUpdated 2027

I am the Chief Executive Officer at Nuvo Health, a company that works with over 200 Medicare agents and brokers across all 50 states to provide no cost, unbiased…

11 more listings in Indiana haven't been claimed yet, so the brokers haven't verified their information, so details may be out of date.

Unclaimed listings

Not yet claimed by the broker. Contact goes through the profile so they can confirm their details.

ALICIA EILER

Unclaimed listing
ALICIA EILERAvon, Indiana

Personalized one-on-one Medicare consultations. No Cost, No Obligation. As an Independent Agent, my aim is to help each consumer find the right products for their…

Ron Van Deusen

Unclaimed listing
Ron Van DeusenPendleton, Indiana

If you’d rather have a local agent (who has been on Medicare for a while) than Joe Namath’s call center, I’m here to help. Call me or text me to set up a meeting.

Kelly Wiseman

Unclaimed listing
Kelly WisemanBirdseye, Indiana

Serving Indiana, Kentucky, Florida and Ohio w/ Medicare Supplements, Advantage & Prescription Drug Plans from multiple carriers. Free no obligation consult.

Sherrie Kramer

Unclaimed listing
Sherrie KramerSouth Bend, Indiana

As a Certified Medicare Professional I can help you find the Medicare plan that fits your individual insurance needs. Call me today for a no cost consultation.

Adam Bauernfiend

Unclaimed listing
Adam BauernfiendEvansville, Indiana

Greetings! I'm Adam, a Medicare insurance agent dedicated to serving your local area. Medicare is my area of expertise, and I'm committed to helping you pinpoint the…

Adam Evrard

Unclaimed listing
Adam EvrardTell City, Indiana

Hi, my name is Adam and I am your local Medicare insurance agent. Medicare is my specialty and I am dedicated to helping you find the best plan that fits your specific…

Adam McHenry

Unclaimed listing
Adam McHenryGreenfield, Indiana

Hello, I'm Adam, your neighborhood Medicare insurance advisor. My expertise lies in the realm of Medicare, and my mission is to assist you in identifying the perfect…

Aaron Patten

Unclaimed listing
Patten Financial GroupValparaiso, Indiana

Hey there, my name is Aaron, and I am your local Independent Fiduciary and Medicare Broker.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find a Medicare broker in Indianapolis?

Browse the listings above to find licensed Medicare brokers serving Indianapolis. Compare their profiles, experience, and specialties, then contact them directly — always free to you.

Are Medicare brokers in Indianapolis free to use?

Yes. Medicare brokers earn commissions from insurance carriers, so their advice and consultations are completely free for consumers.

What's the difference between local and non-resident brokers?

Local resident brokers are based in Indiana. Licensed non-resident brokers hold active Indiana licenses but may work remotely. Both can help you choose the right Medicare plan in Indianapolis.

Explore Medicare Brokers in Other Indiana Cities